Claim Construction Ruling in Arzerra Infringement Case

On October 17, a judge in the Southern District of California issued a significant claim construction ruling in the case of Biogen Idec and Genentech v. GlaxoSmithKline. The plaintiffs allege that defendants anti-CD20 monoclonal antibody Ofatumumab (trade name Arzerra) infringes US patent number 7,682,612. Plaintiffs market a competing anti-CD20 antibody, Rituximab (trade name Rituxan).

Based on my understanding of the case, the ruling appears to be a substantial victory for GlaxoSmithKline.

The disputed claim terms are found in claim 1 of the patent, which recites:

1. A method of treating chronic lymphocytic leukemia in a human patient, comprising administering an anti-CD20 antibody to the patient in an amount effective to treat the chronic lymphocytic leukemia, wherein the method does not include treatment with a radiolabeled anti-CD20 antibody.

The court construed the terms "anti-CD20 antibody” and “CD20 binding fragment” as “rituximab and antibodies that bind to the same epitope of the CD20 antigen with similar affinity and specificity as rituximab” and "the portion of the anti-CD20 antibody that binds to the same epitope of the CD20 antigen with similar affinity and specificity as rituximab.” This is significant, because Arzerra does not bind to the same epitope as rituximab, which appears to rule out infringement if this construction of the terms is affirmed on appeal.

The plaintiffs argued for a broader construction, such that the disputed terms would cover any antibody that binds to CD20, even antibodies that bind to different epitopes, such as Arzerra. However, the court found that the prosecution history of the patent established that during prosecution plaintiffs represented that the claims were limited to antibodies binding to the same epitope as rituximab, and the court held them to this more limited construction of the term.

The court also construed the terms "does not include treatment with a radiolabeled anti-CD20 antibody" and "radiation is not used" as "excludes the use of a radiolabeled anti-CD20 antibody or the administration of a separate radiolabeled anti-CD20 antibody," and "no form of radiation (including radiolabeled antibodies) is used," respectively. This construction is significant, because it appears to rule out infringement when Arzerra is used in conjunction with Bexxar or Zevalin, which are both radiolabeled anti-CD20 antibodies.

Thanks to Docket Navigator for making me aware of the ruling.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

G.M.O.s in Food? Vermonters Will Know

Image
By  STEPHANIE STROM JUNE 30, 2016 Continue reading the main story Share This Page Photo In Vermont, a new law requires products with genetically engineered ingredients to be labeled. Nearly all food labels in Vermont are now required to disclose when products include genetically engineered ingredients. The requirement, passed two years ago, became effective on Friday. The rule is the first of its kind in the United States, and although it applies only within the tiny state, it is having national impact. Most major food and beverage companies have already added language to their labels to meet the new rule, rather than deal with the logistical hassle of having separate labels for different states. Campbell Soup was the first big company to say it would label all of its products, and General Mills, ConAgra, Mars and Kellogg’s followed. But  not all the same products will definitely be on shelves . Coca-Cola said some of its less popular brands may not b...
Read more

Lonza: CMC Product Manager

Due to the expansion of Lonza's Analytical Services department we are looking to recruit an Analytical Product Manager. Reporting to the Group Leader you will proactively coordinate internal and external client project activities (analytical CMC development of recombinant proteins) performed within Analytical Services and to provide scientific oversight of data generated for the projects. Responsibilities:      * Primary point of contact for all analytical activities relating to product development and management of analytical development programmes from early phase development through to license application.      * Primary interface to the Program Management Team, AS study directors and internal and external customers.      * Definition, presentation and representation of analytical CMC programmes to customers, potential new customers & external meetings, including oversight of large analytical portfolio projects.      * Design an...
Read more

Protein folding via charge zippers

Jan. 18, 2013 — Membrane proteins are the "molecular machines" in biological cell envelopes. They control diverse processes, such as the transport of molecules across the lipid membrane, signal transduction, and photosynthesis. Their shape, i.e. folding of the molecules, plays a decisive role in the formation of, e.g., pores in the cell membrane. In the journal Cell, researchers of Karlsruhe Institute of Technology and the University of Cagliari are now reporting a novel charge zipper principle used by proteins to form functional units. "It is fascinating to see the elegant basic principles that are used by nature to construct molecular assemblies," explains Anne Ulrich, Director of the KIT Institute for Biological Interfaces. "A charge zipper between the charged side chains is an entirely unexpected mechanism used by membrane proteins to neutralize their charges such that they can be immersed into hydrophobic cell membranes....
Read more